Address: Judicial Officer: Department: return to top 2022 June Relocation Chart - Judges The last time a judge was ousted was in 2014, after Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Benjamin Norris received a rating from the commission saying he did not meet standards. Judicial candidates are There are serious consequences for people representing themselves and doing so improperly. Beyond those metrics, it's difficult to discern the basis for the commissioners no votes. . And in 2014, Maldonado expected to get a job as a judge at the Maricopa County Superior Court. Privacy Notice WELCOME TO THE ARIZONA JUDICIAL NOMINATING COMMISSIONS WEBSITE. Volunteer-CASA SlovenianSpanish CORP Website This after both a prosecutor and a defense attorney submitted complaints about his treatment of people in court.). JapaneseKorean In December 2022, Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Peter Thompson threw out the lawsuit because Lake failed to provide any "clear and convincing" evidence of irregularities or misconduct . Yiddish Privacy Notice VietnameseWelsh Election fallout:Assistant AG criticized Maricopa County before polls closed, In all three instances, the judges earned lower ratings than their colleagues on their temperament, one of five categories in the survey. Judge Stephen M. Hopkins lost his reelection with only 38% voting to retain him after 15 commissioners on the Commission on Judicial Performance Review found Hopkins to be unfit for the bench. Its another when a couple of no votes proves to be career-ending. Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Phoenix. 1 0 obj The Governor appoints appellate court judges statewide and trial court judges in Coconino, Maricopa, Pima and Pinal counties from lists of nominees submitted by the judicial nominating commissions. Powered by, Arizona Commission on Judicial Performance Review. To see the judicial reports for the judges on your ballot, click on the appropriate court. Only three judges have been rejected in the nearly 50 years since Arizona adopted its judicial retention election system. JapaneseKorean Powered by, Arizona Commission on Judicial Performance Review, To learn more about the Commission watch the short video, Before you vote, read the JPR reports and get the facts about the judges who appear on the ballot so you can be confident and informed when you ". A Maricopa County Superior Court judge and her staff mocked and ridiculed people during hearings and trials by routinely emailing each other cruel and obscene statements, jokes, and. Be an Informed Voter! But the election results also suggest that the votes an independent commission takes, using the surveys as a basis, on whether judges meet standards or not may carry more weight with voters than intended (more on that in a moment). Only seven out of 26 commissioners felt that he met the performance standards. To see the judicial reports for the judges on your ballot, click on the appropriate court. More people are paying attention now.. UkrainianUrdu ALPHA If there is uncertainty regarding a procedure, seek the advice of an attorney. Careers ArabicArmenian ALPHA Ballotpedia provides comprehensive coverage of the 100 largest cities in America by population. Select your county to the left to see a list of all judges that will appear on your ballot and their evaluations or select your county from the drop down below: 2023 Arizona Supreme Court. Legal Reference & Links The Judges overseeing this case are Blaney, Scott and Williams, Paula. Site Map Bolick and Pelander had near-perfect ratings on the surveys and unanimous support from commissioners. Self-Service Center Superior . SerbianSlovak PolishPortuguese Arizona Revised Statutes The Court is assisted by the service of 24 magistrate judges, as well as retired judges who have been recommended and approved as senior judges. That may be so, but part of the outsize effect is baked in because of a couple of other factors involving voters. The Governor appoints. Commissioners are subject to assignments in various departments and for various periods of time to one or more locations of the Court. Volunteer-CASA All Rights Reserved. And another 20% to 25% of voters who do fill in the judges races routinely vote against retention on every judge, regardless of their ratings from surveys and the commission. endobj Theres no evidence of no such effort against Crandell, however. CORP Website To aid voters, the Arizona Commission on Judicial Performance Review evaluates judges and justices. Arizona Revised Statutes The other 46 Maricopa County Superior Court judges on the ballot passed the performance review standards that are posted on the Judicial Performance Review website www . State Bar of Arizona In 1978, voters removed Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Fred Hyder and Arizona Court of Appeals Judge Gary Nelson. Powered by, 2022 Maricopa County Superior Court Commissioners, 2022 Pima County Superior Court Commissioners, 2022 Pinal County Superior Court Commissioners. HindiHungarian It is rare for voters to fire judges. Wenn Sie Ihre Auswahl anpassen mchten, klicken Sie auf Datenschutzeinstellungen verwalten. Self-Service Center 201 W. Jefferson Street to the bench. VietnameseWelsh State of play: Maricopa County Superior Court judges Rusty Crandell, Stephen Hopkins and Howard Sukenic are losing their retention elections, and are down by more votes than are left to count. ArabicArmenian ALPHA Its not hyperbolic to describe the ouster of three Superior Court judges as historic. Superior court judges in smaller counties are still chosen by voters in direct elections. Copies: Hon. This case was filed in Maricopa County Superior Courts, Northeast Regional Court Center located in Maricopa, Arizona. Educator Links Yiddish [emailprotected] Your Service SerbianSlovak GalicianGeorgian ALPHA CORP Website Of the 98 judges, 87 identify as white, four as Hispanic, three as Black, three as Asian and one as Native American. DutchEnglish Self-Service Center The chair of the Judicial Performance Review commission, Mike Hellon, said he believes the process is having the intended effect, although he notes that the percentage of no votes cast by commissioners is not necessarily proportionate to those by voters. MalayMaltese EstonianFilipino Haitian Creole ALPHAHebrew The Commission reviews all applications, All rights reserved. Feedback The Judicial Branch of Arizona In Maricopa County -2023. endobj Privacy Notice 2022 Maricopa County Superior Court Commissioners. Rose Law Group pc values outrageous client service. We pride ourselves on hyper-responsiveness to our clients needs and an extraordinary record of success in achieving our clients goals. On Twitter:@abekwok. Crandell may stand a chance in securing reelection as hundreds of thousands of ballots remain to be counted. By Howard Fischer | Capitol Media Services The way MattGresssees it, a personisa person, no matter how small or even if not born yet, By Camryn Sanchez | Arizona Capitol Times The Senate passed a resolution March 1 that would allow the previous years budget to go into effect, By Camryn Sanchez | Arizona Capitol Times Senate Republicans voted on Thursday to ban foreign groupsfrom buying Arizona land but would not stop a land. Maricopa County voters will decide to keep or. El Centro de Autoservicio, Contact Us Hopkins stood as an outlier as 73 other judges met judicial standards, according to assessments from commissioners, though both Sukenic and Crandell had commissioners vote against them. Only three judges have been rejected in the nearly 50 years since Arizona adopted its judicial retention election system. VietnameseWelsh ArabicArmenian ALPHA LithuanianMacedonian Self-Service Center Gress wants to expand tax credits to cover time woman is pregnant, Resolution cuts governor out of budget process, Senate passes ban on certain foreign groups owning Arizona land, Arizona appeals court rejects Kari Lakes challenge of election loss to Gov. State of play: Maricopa County Superior Court judges Rusty Crandell, Stephen Hopkins and Howard Sukenic are losing their retention elections, and are down by more votes than are left to count. There are suggestions that Crandell may have been the target of special-interest groups, as was the case of state Supreme Court Justices Clint Bolick and John Pelander in 2018 over a ruling to toss a tax-the-rich education funding measure off the ballot. In Maricopa County, where he had served as county attorney, he actually lost by a couple of percentage points. And that judges have been put on notice that their temperament could cost them their jobs. Human Resources, Volunteer Judicial Performance Reports It's easy to be an informed voter. Those judges must stand in retention elections every four years in which voters decide whether to keep them on the bench. Presiding Judge All Juvenile Court Judges and Commissioners Raymond Billotte, Judicial Branch Administrator Chief Eric Meaux, Juvenile Probation Department Cheri Clark, Deputy Court Administrator Paula Collins, Juvenile Department Administrator All Maricopa County Justices of the Peace MalayMaltese Volunteer-CASA AfrikaansAlbanian Career Opportunities Merit selection is a way of choosing judges that usesnonpartisan commissionsto investigate and evaluate applicants for judgeships. In Maricopa County Superior Court, Presiding Criminal Court Judge Patricia Starr, Presiding Family Court Judge Bruce Cohen and Presiding Civil Court Judge Pamela Gates are on. On 03/23/2022 Stephanie Joy Ritter filed a Family - Other Family lawsuit against Darrell Ray Ritter. Comments from the surveys and discussions commissioners have with judges and among themselves arent divulged. Justice Bill Montgomery received two do not meet standards votes this year and was also targeted by a grassroots campaign. The case status is Disposed - Other Disposed. The Superior Court of the Judicial Branch of Arizona in Maricopa County is dedicated to providing a safe, fair, and impartial forum for resolving disputes, enhancing access to our services, and providing innovative, evidenced-based practices that improve the safety of our community and ensure the public's trust and confidence in the Judicial Branch. Get posts youll want to read find us on Facebook! This cycle, the commission deemed one judge, Stephen Hopkins, as unfit for the bench. CzechDanish GermanGreek IcelandicIndonesian Voters have the power to remove or retain judges during the retention elections. Reach Abe Kwok atakwok@azcentral.com. Azerbaijani ALPHABasque ALPHA [emailprotected] Your Service Judges are appointed through a merit process. Applicants for judicial appointment are screened by the Commission on Trial Court Appointments, a non-partisan committee. He is currently assigned to the Family Court Division of the Maricopa County Superior Court. selected for their legal ability and professional and personal achievements PolishPortuguese On the Arizona Court of Appeals, five judges are up for retention: Cynthia Bailey, Michael Brown, Kent Cattani, David Gass and Steven Williams. 2 0 obj Statewide, five Arizona Court of Appeals judges and two other Arizona Supreme Court Judges led in favor of retention. Before you vote, read the JPR report before you vote on the judges on your ballot. Superior Court Commissioners Commissioners are appointed by the Court's Presiding Judge from attorneys who apply and are recommended by a selection committee made up of judges, lawyers and others. Commission on Judicial Conduct GermanGreek Site Map It is rare for voters to fire judges. PolishPortuguese Careers He was reprimanded in 2020 by another independent panel, the Commission on Judicial Conduct, over a pattern of rudeness toward attorneys and defendants. GermanGreek ThaiTurkish Voters also rejected Judge Rusty Crandell, with 51% voting against his retention and Judge Howard Sukenic, with rejection from 59% of voters. %PDF-1.7 Commission on Judicial Conduct FinnishFrench MalayMaltese Stay up to date with the latest news on all things JPR and find out about upcoming meetings with the commission or conference team. Commission on Judicial Conduct Prior to serving as a Commissioner, Judge Covil worked as an Administrative Law Judge for the Arizona Department of Transportation (ADOT) from 2013 to 2018, and began his career as a Maricopa County Public Defender from 2008 to 2013. stream xN=RaU#EHr>cG|SU=p={Uw{wU.e~Y^L.\~klE9_^TWei <>/ExtGState<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 612 792] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>> fechar. National Center for State Courts He lost, but so did Judges Howard Sukenic and Rusty Crandell, who both received more meet standards than do not meet standards votes. Arizona Supreme Court communications director Aaron Nash says those surveys are then reviewed by the judicial performance review commission. Maricopa County Superior Court judge Stephen Hopkins was reprimanded for unprofessional conduct after a prosecutor and a public defender joined in on a complaint. -- Select language -- CzechDanish Hopkins stood as an outlier as 73 other judges met judicial standards, according to assessments from commissioners, though both Sukenic and Crandell had commissioners vote against them. AfrikaansAlbanian Klicken Sie auf Alle ablehnen, wenn Sie nicht mchten, dass wir und unsere Partner Cookies und personenbezogene Daten fr diese zustzlichen Zwecke verwenden. Hellon notes that efforts in recent years to better publicize the commissions work have paid off, including having the judges ratings moved to the front of the voters guide. Of note: Crandell is one of 15 finalists for three positions on the Court of Appeals Division I which will be selected by Gov. Commissioners share supervision of their Judicial Assistants with Court Administration. The Governor appoints appellate court judges statewide and trial court judges in Coconino, Maricopa, Pima and Pinal counties from lists of nominees submitted by the judicial nominating commissions. Services provided via partnerships of Maricopa County, AZ Clerk of Superior Court. FinnishFrench General Information (520) 724-4200 Case Information (520) 724-4200 Juror Information (520) 724-4222 Court Administration (520) 724-4217 Clerk of Court (520) 724-3200 201 W. Jefferson Street GalicianGeorgian ALPHA ArabicArmenian ALPHA The judges' races are left blank on 40% or more of ballots in Maricopa County the percentage was even higher before a "Finish the ballot" campaign in recent years. Arizona Revised Statutes Career Opportunities IrishItalian Chinese (Traditional)Croatian PolishPortuguese (Hopkins ouster is more readily apparent. 3 0 obj Phoenix, AZ 85003. Legal Associations Search court cases for free, read the case summary, find docket information, download court documents, track case status, and get alerts when cases are updated. Commissioner, Maricopa County Superior Court : 2003 - 2009: Litigation Associate, Squire, Sanders & Dempsey, LLP : . All Rights Reserved. Flashback: Voters had only rejected judges three times prior to this year's election. PHOENIX Failed gubernatorial candidate Kari Lake is making a last-ditch effort to overturn the election with an attack on the Court of Appeals which had rejected her claims. Locations; Case Information; Make a Payment; Marriage Licenses & Passports; Records & Minute Entries; Filings; Make an Appointment; Court Forms; NorwegianPersian Chinese (Traditional)Croatian [emailprotected] Your Service Interpreters MalayMaltese Educator Links If you need legal advice, please contact an attorney in your community who can assess the specifics of your situation. FinnishFrench Court Interprentation And Translation Services, 2022 June Relocation Chart - Commissioners, Capital Defense Attorney, Maricopa County Public Defender's Office, Trial Attorney, Maricopa County Public Defender's Office, Bachelor of Arts, Economics and Political Science, 2002, Western Washington University, State Bar of Arizona, Criminal Practices and Procedures Committee, Arizona Supreme Court Task Force: Rules of Criminal Procedure, Volunteer Coach/Judge: Arizona State University Moot Court, Volunteer, Arizona State University Mediation Team, Volunteer, National Parliamentary Debate Association. The no votes of commissioners make the fate of judges more precarious than ever. AfrikaansAlbanian IrishItalian Interpreters EstonianFilipino DutchEnglish Chinese (Traditional)Croatian . State Bar of Arizona EstonianFilipino SwahiliSwedish endobj Site Map Staff Login, Translate this Page: % DutchEnglish Toggle navigation. Azerbaijani ALPHABasque ALPHA Court Vacancies He was denied. Superior Court Judges Judges are appointed through a merit process. Judicial Officer: Department: return to top And that the performance-review process itself could use greater transparency and explanation. Crandell and Sukenic met the standards, but by relatively low votes. Legal Associations ThaiTurkish ThaiTurkish Volunteer-AmeriCorps, Helpful Links View a printable list of judges eligible for retention in the 2022 General Election. Educator Links The commissions then submit the names of at least three highly qualified applicants to the Governor. State Bar of Arizona Judge Pro Tempore, Maricopa County Superior Court; return to top. Careers Rose Law Group Reporter, which provides Dealmakers content and service, is contracted by Rose Law Group. That is, a judge who receives one or two no votes from commissioners may win a retention election by a similar margin as one who gets four or five no votes. In Crandells case, he got a nod from 18 of the 20 commissioners who voted. Hopkins and Crandell oversaw criminal cases. Commissioners might bristle at the suggestion that no votes have an outsize impact on retention election results. SIGN UP NOW Contact Us jpr@courts.az.gov (602) 452-3098 (602) 452-3652 Arizona Supreme Court Court Vacancies Careers 2023 Arizona Supreme Court. [emailprotected] Your Service Commissioners handle specific assigned cases and uncontested matters. The judges races are left blank on 40% or more of ballots in Maricopa County the percentage was even higher before a "Finish the ballot" campaign in recent years. HindiHungarian CatalanChinese (Simplified) <>/Metadata 84 0 R/ViewerPreferences 85 0 R>> Yiddish Between the lines: All three judges got relatively poor reviews from the Arizona Commission on Judicial Performance Review, which was established in 1992 to set performance standards. Bei der Nutzung unserer Websites und Apps verwenden wir, unsere Websites und Apps fr Sie bereitzustellen, Nutzer zu authentifizieren, Sicherheitsmanahmen anzuwenden und Spam und Missbrauch zu verhindern, und, Ihre Nutzung unserer Websites und Apps zu messen, personalisierte Werbung und Inhalte auf der Grundlage von Interessenprofilen anzuzeigen, die Effektivitt von personalisierten Anzeigen und Inhalten zu messen, sowie, unsere Produkte und Dienstleistungen zu entwickeln und zu verbessern. Court Interprentation And Translation Services, 2022 June Relocation Chart - Commissioners. Legal Associations Lindsay Abramson : Melody Harmon : Casey Newcomb : Richard Albrecht: Roger Hartsell: Richard Nothwehr: Glenn Allen: Richard Hinz : Bernard Owens: DutchEnglish In recent elections, were seeing one no vote has about 2, 3 or 4 percentage points effect at the polls, he said. AfrikaansAlbanian Learn how the Commission on Judicial Performance Review evaluates the judges through public input and how voters cans use that information to decide which judges should be retained at election time. Maricopa County voters will decide to keep or get rid of 47 Maricopa County Superior Court judges. Get a free daily digest of the most important news in your backyard with Axios Phoenix. Commissioner Amy KALMAN Current Assignment: Criminal Department Phoenix Assignment History: Work History: Education: Juris Doctorate, 2006, Duke University Bachelor of Arts, Economics and Political Science, 2002, Western Washington University Committees/Associations: State Bar of Arizona, Criminal Practices and Procedures Committee Judicial Officer: Department: return to top 2022 June Relocation Chart - Judges Commissioners handle specific assigned cases and uncontested matters. ,7/x=/gH_=[$ie"Tjnk2LO=X.wh>VNA_5*W>'I8g?b=p!8xN $clzHiR5w ;hH. The courts where the judges work send out surveys to litigants and attorneys who practice in front of the judges, as well as witnesses, jurors and court staff. This page lists judges appointed by Doug Ducey (R) during his term as Governor of Arizona. BelarusianBulgarian Home/AZ Courts/Superior Court Commissioner Review Superior Court Commissioner Review Superior Court Commissionersare appointed by the Court's Presiding Judge from attorneys who apply and are recommended by a selection committee made up of judges, lawyers and others. Juvenile Court Services. The commission is restricted on what it can disclose, so there no summary or details explaining the votes that are used to guide voters. Site Map National Center for State Courts The Justice Courts address minor cases, perform marriages, grant licenses, and more. EstonianFilipino Volunteer-AmeriCorps, Helpful Links Commissioners handle specific assigned cases and uncontested matters. Katie Hobbs for four Hopkins was the only Maricopa County judge who. The commissions then submit the names of at least three highly qualified applicants to the Governor. Interpreters Home / AZ Courts / Superior Court Commissioner Review / 2022 Maricopa County Superior Court Commissioners. Access March 2023 court records for Maricopa County Superior Court, AZ. RomanianRussian Legal Associations Maricopa County, Arizona, held general elections for board of supervisors, constables, water conservation district board, healthcare district board, community college board, clerk of the superior court, justices of the peace, and superior court judges on November 8, 2022. SwahiliSwedish Legal Reference & Links In fact, judges who got an overall thumbs down or multiple do not meet standards votes from the Commission on Judicial Performance Review in previous years survived their retention elections just fine. She earned a bachelor's and master's degrees in broadcast and electronic communication arts from San Francisco State University. Heading into this years election, Arizona voters had removed only three judges under the retention system, two of them in 1978 when the system first went into effect. All rights reserved. She earned her law degree from Golden Gate University Law . RomanianRussian Interpreters Its worth noting that a fraction of the lawyers, litigants and jurors who receive the surveys complete and return them. SwahiliSwedish Catch up:Once-powerful Arizona attorney faces prison in sexual assault, abuse case. El Centro de Autoservicio, Contact Us Hobbs inauguration list, Adrian Fontes asks attorney general to investigate Kari Lake for posting voter signatures online. There are two Regional Court Centers in Maricopa County where preliminary hearings and arraignments are consolidated into one event at one location to expedite the criminal justice process primarily for lower level offenses. BelarusianBulgarian But in the Maricopa County Superior Court Judges' retention. Volunteer-FCRB Azerbaijani ALPHABasque ALPHA GermanGreek FinnishFrench BelarusianBulgarian Legal Reference & Links CatalanChinese (Simplified) Superior Court judges in Maricopa County, Pima County and Pinal County are appointed through the merit selection process. <> Commissioners are appointed by the Court's Presiding Judge from attorneys who apply and are recommended by a selection committee made up of judges, lawyers and others. SerbianSlovak Get more Tweets that make Twitter worthwhile! A large swath of voters who turn out to vote simply ignore the section on judges retention. Arizona Commission on Judicial Performance Review, rejected Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Benjamin Norris. Career Opportunities maricopa county superior court calendar. SwahiliSwedish But even Hellon acknowledges that the case of Crandell, who got only two no votes but lost retention nonetheless, will likely prompt the commission to have a discussion. RomanianRussian -- Select language -- As of March 2023, the total number of Ducey appointees was 97. NorwegianPersian . <> SlovenianSpanish The last time a judge was ousted was in 2014, after Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Benjamin Norris received a rating from the commission saying he did not meet standards. Get the facts, be informed, and be confident when you Finish the Ballot! Maricopa County Superior Court - Northeast Regional Center 18380 North 40th Street Phoenix,Arizona United States 85032 602-506-3204 Mon-Fri 8:00am to 5:00pm Judges divisions are closed daily from 12:00pm to 1:30pm Passport applications cease at 4:00pm Contact Contact Information Court Administration #602-506-3204 Staff Login, Translate this Page: SlovenianSpanish Latin ALPHALatvian Haitian Creole ALPHAHebrew Haitian Creole ALPHAHebrew Superior Court Commissioners Commissioners are appointed by the Court's Presiding Judge from attorneys who apply and are recommended by a selection committee made up of judges, lawyers and others. Phoenix, AZ 85003. Home / AZ Courts / Superior Court Commissioner Review / 2020 Maricopa County Superior Court Commissioners.